Mortgage & Protection Blog

  • Home /
  • Mortgage & Protection Blog

Understanding the FCA’s Discussion Paper: Potential benefits… and risks

24 July 2025

Bob Hunt

Bob Hunt

24 July 2025
As you might have anticipated, my latest article is going to delve a little into the Financial Conduct Authority's (FCA’s) Discussion Paper (DP) 25/2, because it clearly has the potential to be seismic for all mortgage market stakeholders, not least advisers.

In perhaps a break from what you might anticipate – and in true SWOT (strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats) analysis style – I wanted to use this piece to look firstly at the S and the O of the DP, the strengths and opportunities, before a further article looks at the weaknesses and threats. 

The Good 
So, let’s start with what I think could emanate out of this; those suggestions within the DP that have the potential to be turned into tangible shifts and deliver some key benefits to advisers in a brave new mortgage world.

First, there is a recognition by the FCA that the market has evolved considerably since the Mortgage Market Review (MMR) over a decade ago, and its current rules may no longer work as efficiently or fairly for many borrower groups.

The paper is peppered with talk about flexibility, which we should hope will not weaken consumer protections, but potentially rebalance a market that some believe has become a bit too risk-averse. This, it has to be said, is not a belief held by all, although of course we await to see what this may actually mean in tangible rule changes and their impact. 

Benefits to advisers and borrowers
Advisers may well be beneficiaries of such a move, particularly if the regulator is opening the door to a more inclusive approach to affordability. 

Take, for example, the potential changes to how lenders assess affordability for first-time buyers, self-employed borrowers, credit-impaired customers and those with variable income. There are clearly potential borrowers within such groupings who have not been able to meet existing affordability requirements, even though they are sometimes paying more in rent each month than they would for a mortgage.

Therefore, the idea of a rent-based affordability assessment – while still up for debate – could signal a sea change. If realised, it may well give advisers new tools to serve clients who have previously been excluded despite demonstrable track records of managing monthly housing costs. 

It’s not a silver bullet, but for advisers, it could be a chance to revisit client segments that have been parked for too long, and to support customers whose financial profile doesn’t fit neatly into a tick-box model. 

A similar argument could be made with regards to the five-year fixed rate stress test. If this is refined or replaced with a more dynamic, centralised model – or even if more lenders feel confident to use existing flexibility – it could open up access and potentially lead to more product activity and more successful applications for clients. 

A Truly Holistic Market 
Later life lending is another area where the DP has (finally?) found its voice.

The regulator seems to acknowledge what many of us have known for years, that retirement savings won’t cut it for a significant number of people, and housing equity will have to do more of the heavy lifting.

Encouraging more flexible products, and acknowledging the growing relevance of hybrids, drawdown facilities, and low-start mortgages, could significantly increase the range of options available.

For advisers, this means greater scope to add value through bespoke later life planning and more tailored, long-term advice. However, this is going to, in my view, require a change in terms of adviser qualifications and authorisations to do business in this space.

In that sense, the mention of ‘holistic advice’ in later life lending is interesting. The DP references shortcomings in the current approach, where advice can be narrow and product-led, rather than encompassing the full range of client needs.

If the FCA moves to encourage or even mandate more holistic advice models, it would likely increase the demand for fully qualified, multi-skilled advisers able to work in all sectors of the market.

Those already investing in wider qualifications – such as lifetime mortgages – stand to benefit, as the bar could be raised if this becomes a mandatory element of being an adviser.

More Dynamic Thinking 
Another aspect within the DP is its openness to digital innovation. The FCA recognises consumer understanding and engagement could be improved by letting firms innovate with artificial intelligence (AI), smart eligibility tools, and more personalised disclosure methods.

While some of this might feel like it’s geared towards lenders and platforms – which, of course, could be a threat to adviser business/income – it could also benefit advisers who embrace technology. Think client onboarding tools that pre-assess eligibility, AI-powered suitability reports that save hours of admin, or digital disclosures that help ensure Consumer Duty compliance.

It’s already happening. 

If regulators give advisers the freedom to harness these tools without tripping compliance wires, we may finally see a tech-enabled advice sector that doesn’t have to make any compromises and could be used as a shield against any attempts to row back on adviser distribution channels by lenders.

Of course, with all of this comes the need to stay close to developments and engage with the DP process. But for now, there’s a window of opportunity here to shape a more inclusive mortgage market and for advisers to be the main beneficiaries of this.

That said, we must also recognise this is not the whole story. Next time, I’ll take a look at the other side of the SWOT coin because, as much as there’s promise, there’s also potential peril if the industry – and the regulator – doesn’t get the detail right.

24 July 2025

Understanding the FCA’s Discussion Paper: Potential benefits… and risks


16 July 2025

From Niche to Necessary: Why Specialist Lending is the New Normal


15 July 2025

What does the FCA actually want for mortgage borrowers?


27 June 2025

When 'perfect’ isn’t good enough – the strange case of the regulator and mortgage risk


16 June 2025

Working together to fight home insurance fraud


29 May 2025

Help all your clients protect what’s important with Refer & Protect


23 May 2025

Execution-only or (Consumer) Duty of care? The FCA can’t have it both ways


21 May 2025

FCA’s latest Consultation Paper seeks to diminish the value of advice once again


8 May 2025

Keep your eyes on the business, but don’t stop scanning the horizon


1 May 2025

Is 5 a Magic Number?


28 April 2025

Downsizers, downhill skiers and classic car collectors – how regulated bridging can help


24 April 2025

The mortgage market resurgence commands equal measures of hope and caution


16 April 2025

Trump, tariffs, and the rise of later life lending


14 April 2025

Impact of US Tariffs on UK Property Investors: A Market Analysis


20 March 2025

How the FCA’s mortgage proposals could undermine consumer protection


17 March 2025

Is ‘cashing out’ leading to worse outcomes for borrowers?


13 February 2025

First-time buyers still driving market


6 February 2025

FCA ‘Dear CEO’ Letter to Mortgage Intermediaries


10 January 2025

The 2025 PT shift will be dictated by an attractive remortgage market


9 January 2025

Read Between The Lies – Mortgage Fraud in 2025


19 December 2024

Housing Market: 2025 Outlook


28 November 2024

Suppressing landlord activity won’t automatically improve first-time buyer prospects


25 November 2024

The Co-operative Bank for Intermediaries, streamlining processes and expanding product ranges


21 November 2024

Better off dead? The need for critical illness cover


18 November 2024

What the OBR’s five year forecasts mean for the market


25 October 2024

Advisers should rethink their regulatory status to keep up with sector changes


16 October 2024

Your Business Matters


7 October 2024

What may impact BTL and Resi markets in 2025?


1 October 2024

Why Gen Z could be the perfect match for protection


30 September 2024

Self-employed mortgages can be easy, if you choose the right lender


26 September 2024

Lenders and regulators must be careful not to add to adviser disillusion


19 September 2024

There may be trouble ahead…


2 September 2024

Source Go: The Modern Answer to the GI Question


29 August 2024

Pre- and post-mini Budget remortgagors need guidance in transformed market


23 August 2024

Guardian's 2023 claims report: a milestone worth celebrating


14 August 2024

Rate cuts are a positive story for advisers


1 August 2024

The mortgage market is set for a teeming H2


29 July 2024

Aldermore are backing more of your clients to go for it


22 July 2024

YOU SAID, WE DID!


12 July 2024

A surge of optimism for the market


3 July 2024

Consumer Duty one year on – what might happen next?


24 June 2024

How to increase your protection business


17 June 2024

Consumer Duty will mark new era of continuously changing advice


6 June 2024

Mental Health Matters: Workplace Wellbeing


21 May 2024

Advise or refer? Ensuring the best possible outcomes for your clients


15 May 2024

Darlington Criteria Updates


14 May 2024

And The Wait Goes On


10 May 2024

Cap on broker fees sparks industry debate


1 May 2024

Expect the unexpected


15 April 2024

Ready, set, remortgage!


12 April 2024

How the mortgage market is failing new arrivals to the UK


11 April 2024

A compliance refresh will lighten unavoidable market stress


4 April 2024

What is driving the Specialist Residential and Buy-to-Let markets this year?


4 April 2024

A Government that prioritises owner occupiers at the expense of the PRS


28 March 2024

What is your website for?


19 March 2024

Exploring the value of value added benefits


4 March 2024

Artificial intelligence – friend or foe to advisers?


9 February 2024

Trust your own gut when listening to market predictions


8 January 2024

The Name's Bond...


Paradigm

THIS SITE IS FOR PROFESSIONAL INTERMEDIARY USE ONLY AND NOT FOR USE BY THE GENERAL PUBLIC.

APCC MemberConsumer Duty Alliance

Paradigm Consulting is a Member of the Association of Professional Compliance Consultants and also the Consumer Duty Alliance.

Paradigm Consulting is a trading name of Paradigm Partners Ltd
Office address: Paradigm Partners Ltd, Paradigm House, Brooke Court, Wilmslow, Cheshire, SK9 3ND
Paradigm Partners Ltd is registered in England and Wales. No.09902499. Registered Office: As above

Paradigm Mortgage Services LLP
Office address: 1310 Solihull Parkway, Birmingham Business Park, Birmingham B37 7YB
Registered in England and Wales. Company No: OC323403. Registered Office: Paradigm House, Brooke Court, Lower Meadow Road, Wilmslow, SK9 3ND
Paradigm Mortgage Services LLP is a Limited Liability Partnership.

Paradigm Protect is a trading name of Paradigm Mortgage Services LLP
Office address: 1310 Solihull Parkway, Birmingham Business Park, Birmingham B37 7YB
Paradigm Mortgage Services LLP is registered in England and Wales. Company No: OC323403. Registered Office: Paradigm House, Brooke Court, Lower Meadow Road, Wilmslow, SK9 3ND
Paradigm Mortgage Services LLP is a Limited Liability Partnership.