FCA pension transfer advice: don’t be confused by the label

Graeme Stewart

Graeme Stewart

12 August 2021

In the ‘background’ section of the Finalised Guidance Paper FG21/3 Advising on Pension Transfers (March 2021) the FCA states: 

"We are publishing this guidance to help firms give suitable advice consistently. After reading this guidance, some firms may need to make changes to their processes where their approach falls short of the standards set out in the guidance.  

These changes are likely to include the way in which firms:  

  • Collect information about their client’s circumstances to give suitable advice 
  • Use the information they collect to assess whether a DB transfer is suitable 
  • Communicate their advice effectively to consumers"

But don’t be confused by the label.  

This paper is essential reading for any adviser, whether they give advice on DB transfer business, term insurance, a mortgage or an Isa. The paper sets out FCA expectations in relation to DB transfer business, but the guidance and myriad of good and poor examples that are provided by the FCA set out their expected standards, which could be applied to any type of business. 

We believe this is essential CPD reading for an SMF 16, adviser or administrator/para-planner. Here are some of the key take-aways. 

Key points (suitability, suitability, suitability) 

Income and expenditure 

The FCA expects a detailed breakdown of income and expenditure, and some analysis of any anticipated changes. The FCA likes to see income broken down into: 

  • Essential (bills that need paying, and a client would find difficult to stop or reduce) 
  • Lifestyle (that supports the client’s standard of living, for example holidays and eating out, these are expenses a client may not want to compromise on) 
  • Discretionary (covering luxury items and gifts that a client may want to make) 

An adviser should also cover the client’s tax position, and where relevant, look at this pre- and post-retirement. 

Holistic advice 

The FCA has an expectation that advisers will gather full information of the client’s assets and take these into consideration when providing advice. For example, if any other assets already held could be used to meet the clients overall financial objectives on a holistic basis. 

As the FCA says: 

“The better you know and understand your client, the more suitable the advice you will be able to give them. So, you should not only get hard facts such as age and occupation, but also soft facts such as feelings and opinions. For example, you should find out how they or their partner feel about guarantees, managing investments or facing the risk of stock market crashes. These discussions help you to understand your clients’ hopes and fears for retirement, how they make decisions and how they got to where they are now.” 

Clients’ health 

It is important, again for any advice over the medium to long term, to consider your client’s health and lifestyle factors such as smoking, drinking and the exercise that they take. The FCA says that many clients fear they will die early, particularly if their own parent died at a younger age. It is important, says the FCA, to state that a client may not inherit a non-genetic condition, and to mention that lifestyles, working conditions and medical treatments have all changed in recent years. Overall an adviser should manage a client’s expectations and consider mortality risk pragmatically. 

Knowledge and experience 

Advisers should be asking about client’s experiences with investments generally. A poor practice highlighted that an adviser asked about previous experiences with investments and found that a client had experience with bank and Building Society deposits and cash Isas. There was no evidence collected that their client had understood or had experience of investing in assets that could fall in value. 

Attitude to risk 

There is no single solution to this, many advisers use ATR tools, which can be a very good starting place, to begin a discussion. 

The three likely concepts to an individual’s risk profile are: 

  1. Willingness to take a risk (risk attitude)
  2. Ability to take risk or risk capacity
  3. The need to take risk, including the need to accept risk to meet an objective, avoiding falling short of a goal or having wealth eroded by inflation

Capacity for loss 

Capacity for loss is defined as the customer’s ability to absorb falls in the value of their investment. 

Many advisers struggle to present to their client just what capacity for loss means in a manner that can be easily understood. This should always be closely aligned with the client’s knowledge, experience and attitude to risk. It is also unlikely that FCA expectations can be met, if the essential, desired and discretionary expenditure is not fully understood and evidenced.  

The FCA states (as a good practice example): “as well as assessing each client’s financial capacity for loss, a firm considered their client’s degree of comfort with accepting loss. Although Ms Singh could manage by withdrawing £200 less each month, she did not want to cut her income by more than £100 each month. So, her investment risk profile was based on the lower of the level of loss that she could afford to suffer and the level of loss that she was willing to accept.” 

Client objectives and needs

The key to meeting FCA expectations is being able to clearly establish the client needs and objectives. Such needs and objectives have to be personalised to each client, never presented on a generic basis. The FCA states “The aim of establishing the client’s objectives is to understand their priorities and what motivates them.” 

Here the FCA provides a number of good and poor examples, which again, could apply to any type of advice being provided. 

The FCA is keen that adviser’s uses their personal and questioning skills to uncover motives, needs and objectives. They highlight some poor examples of questions, which are likely to be answered with a “yes” but wont actually provide any insights into what is driving their client. 

Poor questioning examples: 

  • Would you like to retire early?  
  • Do you want to maximise your lump sum?  
  • Do you want to try to increase your pension income?  
  • Do you want flexibility?  
  • Do you want to control your own money? 

Good questioning examples: 

  • ‘To what extent are you prepared to live on a lower income so that you can leave assets to your children?’  
  • ‘How important is it for you to retire early even if this could mean running out of money later in life?’  
  • ‘Why do you want the higher amount of tax-free cash that a flexible arrangement could offer you?’  
  • ‘Why do you want to draw out higher amounts of income in the early years of retirement?’  
  • ‘How comfortable are you with the risk of running out of money in later years, and having to potentially rely on state benefits, if you have drawn higher income from your pensions in early years?’   


Don’t be confused by the label, as we have shown above, the good and poor examples provided by the FCA don’t just apply to DB transfer business, and Paradigm has been providing training and support to our firms to bring this paper to life for all advisers rather than just Occupational Pension Transfer Specialists. 

Reading this blog counts towards your CPD!

Click here to add this session to your Paradigm CPD log.

20 December 2021

The public gets what the Public wants’ - or do they?

10 December 2021

Consultation Paper CP 21/36 “A new Consumer Duty”

7 December 2021

FCA’s Consumer Duty seems like a costly exercise for advisers

2 December 2021

Cyber crime update and reporting requirements

9 November 2021

Who will buy...?

1 November 2021

FCA: Remote working expectations for firms

18 October 2021

Remortgaging: Timing may not even matter this time

8 October 2021

Make stamp duty work for everyone

4 October 2021

Time to talk

1 October 2021

The FCA’s plans to tackle investment harm

27 September 2021

Lack of housing stock means brokers need to work client banks harder

3 September 2021

Let technology do the work in the fast-paced mortgage environment

2 September 2021

Time of new beginnings

18 August 2021

The proof of the pudding

12 August 2021

FCA pension transfer advice: don’t be confused by the label

12 August 2021

Time for a change?

26 July 2021

The engagement conundrum

26 July 2021

"I can’t do it all"

7 July 2021

Paused for breath

6 July 2021

SMCR part two - conduct questions

28 June 2021

Introducing a new us!

17 June 2021

Patches - what are they and why are they so important

17 June 2021

Multi-factor authentication - the simple solution

8 June 2021

SMCR part one - time to take stock

27 May 2021

A reminder of the 'good old bad old' days of protection tech

18 May 2021

Let's not consider any 'reduction' in these as some sort of victory

5 May 2021

Simple methods-calculating client profitability

30 April 2021

If the pandemic has been the mother of invention, it's time to carry on

22 April 2021

Opportunities abound in the market

19 April 2021

Early Movers are Shaping the 95% LTV Market

13 April 2021

Here's a conundrum

8 April 2021

Advice processes for vulnerable clients

29 March 2021

Vulnerable signs for advice firms to watch out for

5 March 2021

Lenders have not got to grips with how the pandemic impacted borrowers

2 March 2021

How Covid has changed our financial lives

2 March 2021

Supply needs to match demand

19 February 2021

Don't overlook product transfers

16 February 2021

Creating a plan for good CPD

5 February 2021

Stamp duty debate a black hole

2 February 2021

Industry wide levy is a head scratcher



APCC Member
Paradigm Consulting is a Member of the Association of Professional Compliance Consultants

Paradigm Consulting is a trading name of Paradigm Partners Ltd
Office address: Paradigm Partners Ltd, Paradigm House, Brooke Court, Wilmslow, Cheshire, SK9 3ND
Paradigm Partners Ltd is registered in England and Wales. No.09902499. Registered Office: As above

Paradigm Mortgage Services LLP
Office address: Wellington House, Starley Way, Birmingham International Park, Solihull, B37 7HB
Registered in England and Wales. Company No: OC323403. Registered Office: Paradigm House, Brooke Court, Lower Meadow Road, Wilmslow, SK9 3ND
Paradigm Mortgage Services LLP is a Limited Liability Partnership.

Paradigm Protect is a trading name of Paradigm Mortgage Services LLP
Office address: Wellington House, Starley Way, Birmingham International Park, Solihull, B37 7HB
Paradigm Mortgage Services LLP is registered in England and Wales. Company No: OC323403. Registered Office: Paradigm House, Brooke Court, Lower Meadow Road, Wilmslow, SK9 3ND
Paradigm Mortgage Services LLP is a Limited Liability Partnership.