Blog

Better off dead? The need for critical illness cover

Shelley Read

Guest Blog Writer: Shelley Read, Senior Protection Technical Manager, at Royal London

21 November 2024
Our recent webinar, “Better Off Dead? The need for critical illness cover,” explores an unfortunate reality for many families impacted by a loved one developing a critical illness.
Without critical illness cover, families are often left with significant financial strain and may even have been financially better off if their loved one hadn’t survived, but clearly the emotional impact is devastating.
 

A history of Critical Illness Cover

Critical illness cover (CIC) was developed in 1983 by Dr Marius Barnard in South Africa and was designed to provide financial support upon the diagnosis of life-changing or life-limiting conditions. He persuaded a life insurer called Crusader Life to develop the world's first critical illness insurance policy, which quickly started to gain traction outside of South Africa and was brought to the UK just two years later. 
 

The stats don’t lie

The webinar highlighted some important figures, revealing a significant gap in protection cover particularly among renters and homeowners, highlighting the need to recommend comprehensive cover to your clients. 
 
  • Only 11% of renters have critical illness cover. 
  • 33% of homeowners with a mortgage have this cover. 
While it’s true that renters may not have a substantial amount to protect like homeowners with mortgages, they still face significant monthly expenses, including rent and utility bills. The majority of people still have the aspiration to buy their own home so if critical illness occurs, individuals may have to dip into those well-earned savings to pay rent, cover their food shop or pay utility bills. Thus, highlighting the importance of having the right policy that will replace the loss of income with minimum impact on savings.
 

Impact of CIC on income 

By offering a steady income rather than a lump sum, this type of cover can provide more practical financial support during challenging times. Income-based CIC can be particularly beneficial for certain client groups: 
 
  • Parents with private school fees: Ensuring that children’s education costs are covered even if a parent falls ill. 
  • Divorced individuals paying child maintenance: Protecting ongoing financial commitments. 
  • Renters: Providing a safety net for monthly expenses in the event of illness. 
  • Families saving for a home: Preserving savings earmarked for a deposit. 


Income protection vs critical illness cover 

Advisers frequently face the question of whether to recommend critical illness cover or income protection. This could include, but not limited to, if they have a mortgage, do they need a lump sum or if they had a critical illness, what's their employee benefits? The ideal solution often involves a combination of both, tailored to the client’s specific needs and circumstances.

It's important to describe the role of critical illness and income protection to clients to help them inform decisions. A client’s budget is also a key factor that needs to be considered and providing quotes to compare lump sums of critical illness versus income-based critical illness and income protection will help clients to make an educated decision. A multi-benefit solution can offer comprehensive protection, reducing the risk of policy cancellations and enhancing client retention.
 

Talking about critical illness to business owners

For business owners, critical illness cover is crucial for both business continuity and succession planning. Key person protection can safeguard the business’s financial stability while shareholder protection ensures fair value for shares and maintains control within the company. Advisers should discuss these options with business owner clients to ensure their enterprises are adequately protected.

There are probably only three exit strategies an adviser may want to raise with the client when facing critical illness and some questions to consider:
 
  • Sell their shares of the business to fund retirement: how much is their share worth? Who might buy the company? How attractive is the business?
  • Leave their share of the business to their partner or children: are they interested in taking over? Do they have the skills to be able to run that business?
  • Work to the end: is it a viable option? How is their health now? What is their health is going to be like in the future? Could it also affect their contributions to their pension?
 

Children’s critical illness cover

This feature allows parents to focus on their child’s recovery without the added stress of financial worries. Advisers should highlight the flexibility of these policies, which can be adjusted as family circumstances change. Children’s CIC, typically added to an adult policy, pays out a percentage of the adult’s sum assured. Just like partial payments, it doesn’t impact the adult’s policy.

It’s important to note, that some insurers, allow children's cover to be added or removed without the need for additional medical evidence. This could be imperative for clients who don’t yet have children and clearly couldn't make a claim on currently. Alternatively, if your client’s children have grown up then you might want to remove them from the plan, giving the client total flexibility.

Looking at some research that's been done around families sadly with a sick child in hospital:
  • 28% said they'd gone cold to avoid using heating at home and increasing those fuel bills.
  • More than 40% had asked families or friends if they could borrow some money.
  • 58% that said that they had cut back on non-essential spending.
These statistic stress the importance of having these types of conversations with both clients with children and those who plan to start a family in future.
 

Conclusion

The webinar explored the importance of critical illness cover. For financial advisers, the key takeaway is the necessity of discussing this type of protection with all clients, regardless of their circumstances. By highlighting the benefits and addressing potential gaps in coverage, you can help clients build robust protection portfolios that offer peace of mind and financial resilience in the face of life’s uncertainties.

For more information please check out our webinar - Better off dead? The need for critical illness cover

You can also view Royal London's recent Insights episode around Critical Illness here
 

Reading this blog counts towards your CPD!

Click here to add this session to your Paradigm CPD log.


18 December 2025

Three weeks on from the Budget, the dust has settled but concerns remain


11 December 2025

How Lenders’ New Freedoms are Undermining Client Relationships


8 December 2025

Navigating the Autumn Budget: What It Means for Mortgages and How Accord is Responding


4 December 2025

Ministerial letter on cyber security to small businesses


25 November 2025

AI: from uncertainty to opportunity


11 November 2025

What the Chancellor’s pre-Budget words may mean for the housing market


10 November 2025

Budget via the rumour mill creates no bread for anyone


30 October 2025

Why first-time buyers need advice as well as incentives


8 October 2025

Stamp duty shockwaves fade as landlords get set to expand


29 September 2025

A Broker’s Guide to Busting Mortgage Barriers for Homebuyers


22 September 2025

The government has now confirmed the next Budget will take place on 26 November


17 September 2025

The FCA’s AI vision – opportunity for advisers or a threat to advice?


15 September 2025

Just one week left to make the case for advice


10 September 2025

Economic abuse: What is it and who is at risk?


1 September 2025

Beyond student lets: the rise of HMOs


15 August 2025

Just because the option exists, doesn’t mean it should be taken


12 August 2025

Understanding the FCA’s Discussion Paper: The other side of the SWOT analysis


24 July 2025

Understanding the FCA’s Discussion Paper: Potential benefits… and risks


16 July 2025

From Niche to Necessary: Why Specialist Lending is the New Normal


15 July 2025

What does the FCA actually want for mortgage borrowers?


27 June 2025

When 'perfect’ isn’t good enough – the strange case of the regulator and mortgage risk


16 June 2025

Working together to fight home insurance fraud


29 May 2025

Help all your clients protect what’s important with Refer & Protect


23 May 2025

Execution-only or (Consumer) Duty of care? The FCA can’t have it both ways


21 May 2025

FCA’s latest Consultation Paper seeks to diminish the value of advice once again


8 May 2025

Keep your eyes on the business, but don’t stop scanning the horizon


1 May 2025

Is 5 a Magic Number?


28 April 2025

Downsizers, downhill skiers and classic car collectors – how regulated bridging can help


24 April 2025

The mortgage market resurgence commands equal measures of hope and caution


16 April 2025

Trump, tariffs, and the rise of later life lending


14 April 2025

Impact of US Tariffs on UK Property Investors: A Market Analysis


20 March 2025

How the FCA’s mortgage proposals could undermine consumer protection


17 March 2025

Is ‘cashing out’ leading to worse outcomes for borrowers?


5 March 2025

Start 2025 smarter: Streamline your financial planning with an exclusive Paradigm member offer


13 February 2025

First-time buyers still driving market


6 February 2025

FCA ‘Dear CEO’ Letter to Mortgage Intermediaries


10 January 2025

The 2025 PT shift will be dictated by an attractive remortgage market


9 January 2025

Read Between The Lies – Mortgage Fraud in 2025


Paradigm

THIS SITE IS FOR PROFESSIONAL INTERMEDIARY USE ONLY AND NOT FOR USE BY THE GENERAL PUBLIC.

APCC MemberConsumer Duty Alliance

Paradigm Consulting is a Member of the Association of Professional Compliance Consultants and also the Consumer Duty Alliance.

Paradigm Consulting is a trading name of Paradigm Partners Ltd
Office address: Paradigm Partners Ltd, Paradigm House, Brooke Court, Wilmslow, Cheshire, SK9 3ND
Paradigm Partners Ltd is registered in England and Wales. No.09902499. Registered Office: As above

Paradigm Mortgage Services LLP
Office address: 1310 Solihull Parkway, Birmingham Business Park, Birmingham B37 7YB
Registered in England and Wales. Company No: OC323403. Registered Office: Paradigm House, Brooke Court, Lower Meadow Road, Wilmslow, SK9 3ND
Paradigm Mortgage Services LLP is a Limited Liability Partnership.

Paradigm Protect is a trading name of Paradigm Mortgage Services LLP
Office address: 1310 Solihull Parkway, Birmingham Business Park, Birmingham B37 7YB
Paradigm Mortgage Services LLP is registered in England and Wales. Company No: OC323403. Registered Office: Paradigm House, Brooke Court, Lower Meadow Road, Wilmslow, SK9 3ND
Paradigm Mortgage Services LLP is a Limited Liability Partnership.