Blog

Stress test removal should be delayed as we figure out cost-of-living impact

Bob Hunt

Bob Hunt

13 July 2022
So, the news is out. From the 1 August the Bank of England (BoE) and Financial Policy Committee (FPC) will no longer require lenders to keep the three per cent interest rate stress test in place when determining affordability for borrowers.

It’s a decision that I’m perhaps not surprised about, although I am certainly surprised at its timing, given the nature of our economy right now, as many are struggling to cope with what might be coming over the horizon.  

Back in January – when the withdrawal of these requirements was first mooted, I wrote a piece which I’m now led to believe was at odds with the majority of those who responded to this consultation. 

According to the Bank of England, of the 27 responses – including four from trade bodies representing mortgage providers and intermediaries – the majority were supportive of withdrawing the affordability stress test. 

This could be a question of semantics though. It could mean that only 14 were supportive and none of them were the trade bodies mentioned, so we should perhaps be somewhat skeptical. However, read some of the reactions to the announcement and make your own views on the nature of this industry ‘support’.  
 
Less of a case for stress test removal 
For me, my view of the situation in January has solidified even further. Indeed, you might well argue that given everything that has happened in between then and now, the case for not removing the requirement has strengthened not weakened. 

Back in January we were not in the middle of a cost-of-living crisis yet and we were not fully aware of what inflation might do or the heights it might reach. We also had not been presented with multiple increases in Bank Base Rate in order to try and curb inflation.  

Timing is everything when it comes to these sorts of decisions. There also has to be an understanding of what the repercussions might be for those borrowers who might get through an affordability door, because of these changes, that would once have closed to them. 

It was therefore interesting to read this from the Bank/FPC: “The consultation feedback did not provide any evidence to suggest that removing the affordability test would have a significant impact on the mortgage or housing markets.” 

No offence to the authors but history is littered with examples, particularly in our sector, where the consequences of such actions were far removed from what was believed to be likely at the time. The regulators should certainly be wary of that and not believe those who say, ‘It won’t cause a problem’, especially if they are likely to be those who benefit the most from a policy change.  
 
Measures already in place 
Now, the argument of course is that there are other measures in place which can do the job just as well without the need for a stress test.  

The Bank/FPC has clearly decided that the loan to income (LTI) ‘flow limit’ – which will not be withdrawn, and which limits the number of mortgages that can be extended to borrowers at LTI ratios at or greater than 4.5 – is going to be more useful in ensuring better underwriting standards. 

However, it was deemed important enough to have the stress test for the past decade or so. As several commentators have pointed out, it does smack of extreme short-term memory loss, which is even more confusing given the stresses on many would-be borrowers’ finances.

Many might surmise that the belt and braces approach we are jettisoning actually provided a core strength for the market and its players. It set in stone what was allowed, and the success of that approach I think is self-evident during this period.  

Again, you might rightfully argue, that this is the very time for retaining such interventions.  
 
What comes next?    
Of course, the big question here I suppose is just what lenders will do having been provided with the ability not to stress test in this manner.  

Will they continue to operate as they have done? Or will they feel that they can further meet the demand that this will help generate, and the previous rules were simply holding them back?  

Lenders, it’s over to you.   

Reading this blog counts towards your CPD!

Click here to add this session to your Paradigm CPD log.


19 December 2024

Housing Market: 2025 Outlook


28 November 2024

Suppressing landlord activity won’t automatically improve first-time buyer prospects


25 November 2024

The Co-operative Bank for Intermediaries, streamlining processes and expanding product ranges


21 November 2024

Better off dead? The need for critical illness cover


18 November 2024

What the OBR’s five year forecasts mean for the market


11 November 2024

Exploring the latest in Defaqto Engage: A comprehensive roundup of new features and enhancements.


25 October 2024

Advisers should rethink their regulatory status to keep up with sector changes


16 October 2024

Your Business Matters


7 October 2024

What may impact BTL and Resi markets in 2025?


1 October 2024

Why Gen Z could be the perfect match for protection


30 September 2024

Self-employed mortgages can be easy, if you choose the right lender


26 September 2024

Lenders and regulators must be careful not to add to adviser disillusion


19 September 2024

There may be trouble ahead…


2 September 2024

Source Go: The Modern Answer to the GI Question


29 August 2024

Pre- and post-mini Budget remortgagors need guidance in transformed market


23 August 2024

Guardian's 2023 claims report: a milestone worth celebrating


14 August 2024

Rate cuts are a positive story for advisers


7 August 2024

Mind the gap (s)...


1 August 2024

The mortgage market is set for a teeming H2


29 July 2024

Aldermore are backing more of your clients to go for it


22 July 2024

YOU SAID, WE DID!


12 July 2024

A surge of optimism for the market


9 July 2024

Distribution of Wealth


3 July 2024

Consumer Duty one year on – what might happen next?


24 June 2024

How to increase your protection business


17 June 2024

Consumer Duty will mark new era of continuously changing advice


6 June 2024

Mental Health Matters: Workplace Wellbeing


21 May 2024

Advise or refer? Ensuring the best possible outcomes for your clients


15 May 2024

Darlington Criteria Updates


14 May 2024

And The Wait Goes On


10 May 2024

Cap on broker fees sparks industry debate


1 May 2024

Expect the unexpected


15 April 2024

Ready, set, remortgage!


12 April 2024

How the mortgage market is failing new arrivals to the UK


11 April 2024

A compliance refresh will lighten unavoidable market stress


4 April 2024

What is driving the Specialist Residential and Buy-to-Let markets this year?


4 April 2024

A Government that prioritises owner occupiers at the expense of the PRS


28 March 2024

What is your website for?


19 March 2024

Exploring the value of value added benefits


4 March 2024

Artificial intelligence – friend or foe to advisers?


21 February 2024

RESTRICTIONS LIFTED?


9 February 2024

Trust your own gut when listening to market predictions


7 February 2024

Strategic thinking - Is this time for a new look at how we work as a business?


8 January 2024

The Name's Bond...


Paradigm

THIS SITE IS FOR PROFESSIONAL INTERMEDIARY USE ONLY AND NOT FOR USE BY THE GENERAL PUBLIC.

APCC MemberConsumer Duty Alliance

Paradigm Consulting is a Member of the Association of Professional Compliance Consultants and also the Consumer Duty Alliance.

Paradigm Consulting is a trading name of Paradigm Partners Ltd
Office address: Paradigm Partners Ltd, Paradigm House, Brooke Court, Wilmslow, Cheshire, SK9 3ND
Paradigm Partners Ltd is registered in England and Wales. No.09902499. Registered Office: As above

Paradigm Mortgage Services LLP
Office address: 1310 Solihull Parkway, Birmingham Business Park, Birmingham B37 7YB
Registered in England and Wales. Company No: OC323403. Registered Office: Paradigm House, Brooke Court, Lower Meadow Road, Wilmslow, SK9 3ND
Paradigm Mortgage Services LLP is a Limited Liability Partnership.

Paradigm Protect is a trading name of Paradigm Mortgage Services LLP
Office address: 1310 Solihull Parkway, Birmingham Business Park, Birmingham B37 7YB
Paradigm Mortgage Services LLP is registered in England and Wales. Company No: OC323403. Registered Office: Paradigm House, Brooke Court, Lower Meadow Road, Wilmslow, SK9 3ND
Paradigm Mortgage Services LLP is a Limited Liability Partnership.